Kids Mysteries

Kids MysteriesKids MysteriesKids Mysteries
Home
Contact Us
About Us
Write for Us
The Pilfered Pooch
Mystery Manor
High-Tech Flavor Heist
The Seaside Inn
The Missing Music
The Mountainside Inn
Strange Island
Haunted Amusement Park
The Trophy Theft
The Swiped Sunflowers
The Soccer Saboteur
The Lost Elephant
The Disappearing Presents
The Costume Conspiracy
The Lost Letters to Santa
Let us stage your mystery
Become an Affiliate
Order Page
About Jack Pachuta

Kids Mysteries

Kids MysteriesKids MysteriesKids Mysteries
Home
Contact Us
About Us
Write for Us
The Pilfered Pooch
Mystery Manor
High-Tech Flavor Heist
The Seaside Inn
The Missing Music
The Mountainside Inn
Strange Island
Haunted Amusement Park
The Trophy Theft
The Swiped Sunflowers
The Soccer Saboteur
The Lost Elephant
The Disappearing Presents
The Costume Conspiracy
The Lost Letters to Santa
Let us stage your mystery
Become an Affiliate
Order Page
About Jack Pachuta
More
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Write for Us
  • The Pilfered Pooch
  • Mystery Manor
  • High-Tech Flavor Heist
  • The Seaside Inn
  • The Missing Music
  • The Mountainside Inn
  • Strange Island
  • Haunted Amusement Park
  • The Trophy Theft
  • The Swiped Sunflowers
  • The Soccer Saboteur
  • The Lost Elephant
  • The Disappearing Presents
  • The Costume Conspiracy
  • The Lost Letters to Santa
  • Let us stage your mystery
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Order Page
  • About Jack Pachuta

  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Write for Us
  • The Pilfered Pooch
  • Mystery Manor
  • High-Tech Flavor Heist
  • The Seaside Inn
  • The Missing Music
  • The Mountainside Inn
  • Strange Island
  • Haunted Amusement Park
  • The Trophy Theft
  • The Swiped Sunflowers
  • The Soccer Saboteur
  • The Lost Elephant
  • The Disappearing Presents
  • The Costume Conspiracy
  • The Lost Letters to Santa
  • Let us stage your mystery
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Order Page
  • About Jack Pachuta

The Terrifying Case of Strange Island

Meet Commander Dink Plotkins!

More about the case!

9 boys are suspects - up to 30 can play

As the sun was setting yesterday, a group of Young Adventurers, along with their two leaders, were stranded on a desert island. The group’s boat engine had failed while passing Strange Island--a rocky, forested place. The boys paddled the boat to the shore. Commander Dink Plotkins tried, but couldn’t fix the engine and the Adventurers set up camp for the night.


As darkness fell, strange noises were heard over the island - moans, shrieks, cries, and a booming sound. After climbing a nearby hill, two brave Adventurers saw bright, swirling lights over the other side of the island, where the booming noise was coming from.


One group went with Commander Plotkins to investigate the other side of the island, while Assistant Commander Vinglesworth stayed at the campsite with the others. Suddenly, a large, shrieking shape appeared in the trees over the campsite, causing panic in the camp.


On the other side of the island, Commander Plotkins and his Adventurers found a cave that pulsed beams of colored light and emitted loud booms. Tracks and claw marks led from the mouth of the cave to the beach, disappearing at the water. Two brave Adventurers volunteered to explore the cave.


Shortly after entering, they emerged, one so scared he could not speak. The other Adventurer had found a glowing claw in the cave. He was holding it in one hand and his friend with the other.


Commander Plotkins and his Adventurers returned to the campsite to find the others terrified and huddled in their tents. The Adventurer who found the claw offered to stand guard as the shrieking figure above circled throughout the night.


In the morning, the campers found the guard asleep, and the flying creature gone--along with their boat engine. Luckily, one of the boys had successfully activated the boat’s emergency transponder, alerting rescuers. Now, the Chief Investigator has arrived and is asking everyone’s help to figure out what happened.

Dark Cave from All-Boy Kids Mystery Party Game Kit, "The Terrifying Case of Strange Island."

Strange Island was filled with hidden caves and dark forests. Who knew what lurked inside them?

Purchase this Kids Mystery for $27.97

Scroll down to find out more about this mystery!
Click HERE to Purchase and Download this mystery for $27.97!

Someone knows what‘s happening!

Campfire from All-Boy Kids Mystery Party Game Kit, "The Terrifying Case of Strange Island."

Commander Dink Plotkins

He's been known to exaggerate what happens so to impress the Young Adventurers. 

Assistant Commander Vinglesworth

He'd love to be in charge, but how would be get Dink Plotkins to leave?  

Donovan Seal

All he thinks about is the Adventurer of the Year award. His family has a tradition of bringing the honor home.  

Rooster Evans

He’s the only one who got a good look at the “cave monster.” 

Stevie Screen

He loves scary movies and is working on his own production.

Plub Eatsweets

He's an amateur ventriloquist and the others kid him about being scared of just about everything. 

Tommy Minky

He loves a good joke and doesn't take anything seriously. 

Zeb Bytes

He's a genius when it comes to technology and can figure out how to do just about anything. 

Gramble Wheadthin VII

He comes from a long line of famous explorers and is a debate champion. 

Frequently Asked Questions

From nine to 30 teens can comfortably participate in the investigation. 


The plot includes nine suspects. They are the only ones with assigned roles. Everyone else becomes an investigator who figures out the details of the case. Since the guilty party doesn't know who did it, all of the teens can attempt to solve the case.


You'll get everything you need to conduct the investigation, including:


- Complete instructions on what to do to solve The Terrifying Case of Strange Island.

- Roles for 9 suspects that include information about who they are and why they might be responsible for what happened.

- Support material and evidence that will help the boys investigate the case.

- "The Solution" that is revealed at the end of the investigation and ties the event together. 


Remember: The teens will have to ask a lot of questions to identify the guilty party.


The total cost is only $27.97 - AND you'll be able to download the entire mystery as soon as your credit card is processed. You'll have a kids mystery party that will keep them talking for months.   


Purchase this Kids Mystery for $27.97

Click HERE to Purchase and Download this mystery for $27.97!

Contact Us

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

  • Let us stage your mystery
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Order Page

PO Box 191, Cedarburg, WI 53012

(262)377-7230

Copyright © 2025 Kids Mysteries - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

DeclineAccept